Life as We Do Not Know It

topic posted Sun, December 18, 2005 - 6:19 PM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Life as We Do Not Know It: The NASA Search for (and Synthesis of) Alien Life
by Peter Ward
Viking, 2005
Hardcover, 292 pp., illus.
ISBN 0-670-03458-4
US$25.95/C$36

From Publishers Weekly:

Ward's Rare Earth (coauthored with Donald Brownlee) suggested the unlikelihood of our finding an alien race as complex and evolved as humankind; if such beings exist, they're too far away for us to make contact with. But what about more basic forms of life right here in our solar system? Ward, an investigator with NASA's Astrobiology Institute, believes researchers might be taking the wrong approach by looking only for earthly DNA-based life forms. Truly alien life, he argues, might have completely different origins; even Earth has untold numbers of viruses composed entirely of RNA, and scientists have created similar genetic material in laboratories, so who's to say silicon-based life-forms are impossible? After introducing readers to the building blocks of life and the new ways they might be arranged, Ward speculates on what types of microbes we might find on other planets and their satellites. He recommends that future manned space expeditions include paleontologists and biochemists to follow up on suggestive evidence collected by space probes. The science is neatly laid out, and readers willing to follow his daring, scientifically based speculations will find their imaginations spurred.

From Booklist:

Paleontologist Ward--who has written previously about extinctions (Gorgon, 2004), evolution (Future Evolution, 2001), and planetary geology (Rare Earth, 2003)--indulges in some freewheeling yet reasonable speculation on what forms of life we are likely to discover on other worlds. In the past five years, astronomers have uncovered much new environmental data on the planets and satellites in our solar system, most notably from the two Martian rovers that are still scuttling about on the surface. The problem with recognizing alien life, as Ward sees it, is that science defines it too narrowly; biologists must expand their definition to encompass forms that do not resemble terrestrial carbon-and-DNA-based packages. He begins by declaring that viruses are alive and goes on to classify other exotic chemical combinations that could evolve in an alien environment. Ward says that machines like the rovers are not set up to detect "life as we do not know it" and that it will take missions with human crews to discover what we don't expect. Certainly thought--provoking.
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Life as We Do Not Know It

    Sun, December 18, 2005 - 7:12 PM
    Oh course that indeed is a possibility, but carbon based life is so damn universally viable as compared to something based on silicone.

    I suspect that the vast majority of life in the Universe is carbon based and require similar conditions parameters as seen on Earth like worlds; to create intelligence to hear or even contact from us…
    • Re: Life as We Do Not Know It

      Sun, December 18, 2005 - 7:13 PM
      Rare Earths, is also one hell of a good book...
      • Re: Life as We Do Not Know It

        Tue, December 20, 2005 - 9:39 PM
        Everything I've heard suggests they are looking for an unexpected amount of order. Or, of course, any kind of mobility, energy transformations, growth, etc. They make machines to detect DNA, I think, but I think most people who are looking for alien life are looking for more than just DNA (though that would be a GREAT indicator) and are unlikely to dismiss a possible life form just because it doesn't contain DNA.
        • Re: Life as We Do Not Know It

          Tue, December 20, 2005 - 10:54 PM
          An irony is I'm watching "Alien Planet" at this moment.

          All we got to examine at the moment is our own world’s life.

          However, let’s say that the Mars rocks really do contain bacterial fossil relics? That is a good sign that DNA is what to look for...
          • B
            B
            offline 121

            Re: Life as We Do Not Know It

            Wed, December 21, 2005 - 7:23 AM
            <Oh course that indeed is a possibility, but carbon based life is so damn universally viable as compared to something based on silicone.>

            You mean that it is so universally viable on this planet which is our only test case to date. Maybe the sample size is a bit small. When we have explored say 10 or 100 planets then maybe we will be able to make statements like that with more authority.

            Kink of like the frog in the pond saying that amphibian life is just so well suited to this enviornment. What else can there be. Ribid.

Recent topics in "Fermi Paradox"